Pine Valley-The Crump Cup

There is a veil of mystery that pervades Pine Valley, consistently on the top of everyone’s list of the most difficult courses in America.  This course was the creation of George Crump, a Philadelphia Hotel man who set out to create a track that would punish every mistake a player makes on the golf course with a bad result.  From everything I have heard about Pine Valley he succeeded masterfully in that effort.

Since Pine Valley is such a private place and they have rarely had national events there, it remains a mystery to most of the interested golf world.  There is one black and white Shell’s Wonderful World of Golf episode you can find on the internet from back in the 1960’s between a young Gene Littler and Byron Nelson.  There have been a couple of Walker Cups played there as well that had some TV time.  But that is about it.  Here are some photos from my day at the ranch.

The chance most people would have to get onto the property of this course in Camden, New Jersey, is during the prestigious four-day amateur invitational event they hold every year called The Crump Cup.  This has been going on since 1922 and has had as it’s winner some of the history’s most distinguished amateurs including Francis Ouimet, Chick Evans, Billy Joe Patton, and Jay Sigel.

The event is two rounds of medal qualifying to establish flights followed by four rounds of match play to determine the champions.  The last round is held on Sunday, this year on October 2nd, and it is discreetly open to the public to enjoy.  You park in the Amusement Park pictured above and get shuttled down a gravel road to a back entrance to the property.   Once inside the fence you are free to roam unfettered about the grounds of one of the most storied courses in America.

They hold this event without much fanfare every fall-usually in September or October.  Not much advertising but I imagine with a little due diligence in August you can get the particulars on how and when to attend.  If you are in the Philadelphia/South Jersey area I am sure attending The Crump Cup would be an experience to remember.

 

October, 2010

Make Room For Butch Harmon

Jim (Bones) Mackay wrote this piece for Golf World expressing his view that they need to induct Butch Harmon into the Hall of Fame. After all, he has been the mentor and teacher of so many Hall of Famers, he should get in by association alone.  Norman, Ballesteros, Couples, Woods, Cink, and Clarke just to name a few.

Butch is his own man, he has a distinctive, no nonsense way of talking to people and it is clearly very effective with his students and pretty entertaining for the rest of us.  Given that there are famous coaches in the Hall of Fame of other sports and for golfers their teachers are their coaches, I like Bone’s logic in this submission.  Butch has always been a guy who breaks the mold we should honor that independence and competence in his craft and give him his due in the Golf Hall of Fame.

(Click here to read Jim Mackay’s article on Butch and The Hall of Fame)

Jim Mackay

October, 2011

Dunhill Links Frantic Finish

Old Tom apparently couldn’t find the real harsh stuff to throw at the players so he had to settle for a Scottish Haar, a coastal fog, to drape over the links at St. Andrews for the final round.  The low ceiling is like playing at dusk all day, it mitigates the depth perception and makes target visualization a strain.  It was chilly enough for hands in the pockets but without a breath of wind the Old Course was without it’s primary defense.

Starting the day five back and a group ahead of the leader Northern Ireland’s Michael Hoey, Rory McIlroy set a blistering pace shooting 30 on the front nine and grabbing the lead at 19 under  at the turn.  It was like Congressional all over again, his lyric swing in perfect balance, his approach play seemingly effortless and precise, and the hole must have looked the size of an ash bin to him.  He missed a makeable birdie on 10 but came right back on the 190 yard 11th, with the hole cut on a small inaccessible shelf on the back of the green, and knocked it stiff for a kick-in birdie to get to 20 under.

Graeme McDowell, the third Ulsterman in the mix, had his chances.  He hit it close a bunch of times but he putted without authority leaving himself hands on knees staring at his shoes wondering where his putting courage was today.

Michael Hoey would not go away.  He was stuck in neutral on the front side with two bogies early and two birdies on eight and nine.  After knocking it within birdie range a number of times on the back he finally converted a short one on fifteen to tie the lead at 20 under.  It was going to be a typical test of will and judgement over the closing holes at the Old Course-the Road Hole looming large between the leaders and the finish.

With Rory watching from the tee on 17, Hoey seized the lead outright knocking it stone dead to a testy pin placement on sixteen for a birdie.  Rory burned the edge on 17 with a long putt from off the front of the green and had to settle for par.  Hoey answered with a par of his own on the Road Hole to maintain his one-shot advantage.

After a well positioned drive on 18, It came down to Rory making a birdie pitch across the Valley of Sin to create a playoff.  Enter in Old Tom for the last word as McIlroy hit the perfect high pitch just behind the hole with what looked like just the right spin to leave it below the hole for an uphill birdie chance.  But after the ball seemed to come to a complete stop it got a finger shove from above and started creeping toward the edge of the false front ending up with a Costantino Rocca leave at the bottom of the hill off the front of the green.  Two putts from there left him stuck at 20 under and a shot behind.

Michael Hoey drove it to center and went the low pitch and run route through the Valley of Sin to leave it inside ten feet below the hole.  As an exclamation point he holed what was left to win by two and etch his name on this prestigious piece of hardware.

This was a fitting finish to what was a gripping day’s play at the ancestoral home of golf.

(Photos from Getty Images/EuropeanTour.com)

October, 2011

My Innermost Swing Thoughts

The difficulty is, all swing thoughts decay, like radium. What burned up the course on Wednesday has turned to lead on Sunday. Yet it does not do to have a blank mind: The terrible hugeness of the course will rush into the vacuum, and the ball will spray like a thing berserk. A swing thought is the golfer’s equivalent of the rock climber’s Don’t look down. With it, we reduce the huge circumambient room for error to a manageable somatic circumference. The score, the stakes, the beer in the clubhouse should all be ousted by some swing thought — which is a swing thought in itself.

John Updike

Swing Thoughts

Golf Dreams-Writings On Golf (1984)

The Walking Golfer

The Walking Golfer is a website dedicated to spreading the word about the benefits of walking the golf course.  In an age where most public, resort, and private courses seem to discourage patrons from walking, it is good that there is someone out there trying to debunk their logic and self-serving economic rationalizations.

(Click here to read their Benefits of Walking)

This site also features course reviews, course walkability ratings, interviews and articles.  You can even join the society as a member for free.

 

Man O’ War Golf Course

Man O’ War is one of two courses Joel Weiman built for the Glen Riddle Golf Club outside of Ocean City, Maryland.  Weiman designed the Uplands Golf Club (of blessed memory) in Denton, Maryland off Route 404 on the way to the Maryland/Delaware Beaches.  Similar to that effort,  here he took a flat piece of farmland and turned it into a very interesting golf course that pulls links style features into play and makes for a wonderful afternoon of golf challenges that we are not used to seeing in this part of the world.  Add the wind factor, since this is just off the Bay side of the Ocean City area, and you do have a course that will give you a new riddle to solve every time you play.

                           Early Wake Up Call on Par 3 Second Hole

Click on any picture to get an enhanced view of the image

Be clear, that in spite of all the marketing hype, this is not a links course.  It lacks many of the inherent environmental necessities of a links course-sandy turf, proximity to a major ocean or sea, tall sand dunes, treeless surroundings.  But, to his credit, Weiman found a way to embed many of the links style challenges in this course-blind shots, random bounces,  awesome topographical intrusions, scantly bunkered green constellations, slick and windswept putting surfaces.  You will have a few of those head scratching “is this too arbitrary” or “is this unfair” kind of thoughts when you think back over your day of golf.  But truth is what you should come away with is a satisfying sense of mental exhaustion from having been challenged throughout the day.

Intimidating Beauty Par 4 #11

What you do get are well manicured Bermuda grass fairways that wend their way through an interesting array of swales and hollows, startling bunker clusters, and imaginative green constellations.  Weiman introduces the links arbitrary bounce feature through the creation throughout the course of what we have coined “Worm Berms”.  When you look at the holes on the GPS imaging in the cart there are manufactured ridges in many fairways that look like worms-these will repel a ball without the proper level of intention to places that seem arbitrary and punitive.  But for anyone who has played across the pond you know that the rub of the fairway is an elemental part of the links golf experience.  The bent greens are severely sloped and segmented with tiers and fall offs that make it essential to plan your approach angles to leave your ball where you can putt aggressively. Being on the wrong side of the hole all day will leave you a bushel full of three putts.  Creative pitching and chipping will go a long way to keeping you on your game-the unusual green constellations will afford you plenty of opportunity to ply that craft.

Like most good courses driving the ball on the right line is essential to success.  Weiman used creative bulldozing to inject some very obtrusive obstacles in your path.  Picking the right club off the tee and the best angle from which to play your next shot will help you negotiate these challenges with much less pain.  The blind shots and other visual misdirection techniques in the architecture will cast further doubt in your mind, but you have to trust your instincts and have conviction of intent on every shot.

Home Hole Par 4 #18

This is a wonderful afternoon of golf with a distinct links flavor to it.  Enjoy the arbitrariness of the experience and go with the flow-you will have some sweet recollections of the day’s challenges if you don’t let it wear you out.

(Photos from gwowi.com)

Berlin, Maryland

Architect: Joel Weiman (McDonald Design Group) 2006

Tees          Par    Rating    Slope    Yardage
Blue          72      71.6       133        6556
Silver        72      69.1       128        6086

(Click to see complete Man O’ War hole-by-hole descriptions)

Your Usual Game

Few things draw two men together more surely than a mutual inability to master golf, coupled with an intense and ever-increasing love of the game………It was pleasanter, they found, to play together, and go neck and neck round the eighteen holes, than to take on some lissom youngster who could spatter them all over the course with one old ball and a cut-down cleek stolen from his father; or some spavined elder who not only rubbed it into them, but was apt, between strokes, to bore them with personal reminiscences of the Crimean War.

.

P.G. Wodehouse

A Woman Is Only A Woman

The Golf Omnibus

Laurel Hill Golf Club

In the early 00’s the DC Department of Corrections closed their Lorton detention facility in Northern Virginia and returned the  property, which included 4000 acres of hilly dairy farm land, to Fairfax County to redeploy for public use.  The county wisely decided to take full advantage of this opportunity to build a high school, an equestrian park, a museum, an athletic complex, an arts center, and a high-end municipal golf course.   With close to 300 acres at his disposal Bill Love, an accomplished designer with an environmentally sensitive approach to course design, was asked to oversee the project and he put together what has turned out to be one of the real gems in the Washington Metro area.

The juxtaposition of the property's former use to it's current use is intriguing.

The juxtaposition of the property’s former use to it’s current use is intriguing.

The golf course he created has stunning aesthetic beauty combined with challenging strategic design and will provide you with an afternoon of sheer golf delight.  Standing on many of the tees you cannot help but stop to appreciate how the holes gently follow the natural flow of the land bringing your attention the sheer beauty of nature’s features therein.  This would be a particularly inspiring experience in October with a little leaf color and a slight chill in the air.

October fall colors are already adding flavor to the driving area on #9.

October fall colors are already adding flavor to the driving area on #9.

The course is built to the top specifications featuring generous bent grass rolling fairways in impeccable condition, over 100 bunkers in places that make you think and think again, rough that will take control out of your hand on recoveries, and firm and fast greens with plenty of interesting contours to consider.

Just one nest of sand madness you must avoid in front of #5 green.

Just one nest of sand madness you must avoid in your path to the #5 green.

On many holes you just have to scratch your chin and ponder the possibilities before you decide how you are going to play effectively.  The county has committed serious budget money to keep this in top flight condition so the consistency of this experience is gratifying. Golfweek Magazine recently put this course as #13 in their list of top municipal courses in the country.  The top 15 on that list include Bethpage Black, Chambers Bay, Torrey Pines, TPC Scottsdale, and Harding Park.  Pretty heady company for our local muni, huh?  Based on this pedigree the USGA held their 2013 Public Links Championships at Laurel Hill.

The uphill climb on the long 439 yard 3rd has plenty of obstacles to

The uphill climb on the long 439 yard 3rd has plenty of other obstacles to consider.

What I like the most about what Love has done is the variety in the types of holes he presents.  The par 71 is not because of only 3 par fives-it is because of 5 par threes and these are some of the most interesting visuals of the day.  You have monster par 4s that are 425 to 450 yards and uphill to boot.  You have reachable Par 5s under 500 yards with major decision making parameters.  Two par threes under 150 and three par threes between 180 and 210.

#14 is 212 yards and a club and half uphill with a three tier green to boot.

#14 is 212 yards and a club and half uphill with a three tier green to boot.

There are steep uphill approaches, dramatic two-club less downhill shots, forced carries over environmental areas, and just some of those approaches where you have to slip it between the this bad thing and that.   Every club in your bag will be dirty when you are done-the variety of shots you are going to be asked to hit will run the full gamut.

There is a natural flow to the design as you see off the tee box on the long par 4 17th.

There is a natural flow to the design as you see off the tee box on the long par 4 17th.

In general the driving areas are wide, but the preferred areas are always cordoned by bunkers or bordering angular topographies.  On a number of the doglegs it is nests of bunkers that are your no-no not trees but trees do frame many of the landing areas and generally define the line of the holes.

The short par 4 7th tempts the bomber but the Jack-O-Lantern bunkering will spook them.

The short par 4 7th tempts the bomber but the Jack-O-Lantern bunkering will spook them.

The greenside bunkering is very imaginative-often nested to one side to force you to work the ball into a green set on the diagonal line of the green.  The greens themselves have lots of segmentation and tiering so you have to be careful to recognize where the pin is located and where the prevailing slope goes to keep your ball under the hole.  There is not much overt water in play but there are some moist ditches and adjacent environmental areas that can lead to double bogies.  Both nines end with a short par five that has real visual and strategic interest.  This gives you a chance for redemption or damnation at the end of each side.

The postcard 16th has alternate tees to change the challenge but not the pleasure of the view.

The postcard 16th has alternate tees to change the challenge but not the pleasure of the view.

The entire facility is done to high standard.  The clubhouse is small but well appointed and functional.  The grass driving range is very roomy and has the same bent grass the course.  The pitching and putting areas have much of the course feature so you can practice the things you will be called on to play during your round. For a municipal fee course price you are really getting a high-end golf product.  This is a must play and needs to be on your short list.

Lorton, Virginia

Architects: Bill Love (2005)

Tee          Par    Rating    Slope    Yardage
Blue         71      73.3       142        6730
White       71      71.7       139        6386

(Click to see complete Laurel Hill hole-by-hole descriptions)

Houdini and The Ouija Board

There is no doubt that Bill Haas played the best golf in the Tour Championship and deserved to win the whole kit and caboodle including two trophies and about $11 million in cash sweeps.  His magical play, especially as the ultimate escape artist on the three playoff holes, will be the remain a thing of legend.  His aquatic recovery on 17 would have made Lloyd Bridges and Woody Austin feel proud.  With this dramatic ending of two of the best young American players locked in battle, logic would say that everyone should be satisfied with this show, the sponsors, the fans, the players, and the tour officials.

But the truth is that the PGA Tour’s attempt to create “Playoff Fever” through the FedEx Cup mechanism is still a disappointing failure.  This has not turned into the back nine at Augusta or the stretch drive to the Super Bowl.  Their inability to communicate clearly to the fans and the players in real time who is gaining ground, who is losing ground, who can win the pot of gold, and who is out of it remains the Achilles Heel of this concept.

To his own admission, Bill Haas did not know he had won the FedEx Cup when he climbed the stairs after sinking the winning putt.  If he did not know for sure he was putting for the $11 million how compelling is this competition.

Let’s be honest, if you watched the broadcast of the final round there is no way you had a sense of how your personal favorite was doing until Steve Sands got on with a white board and a dry erase marker and penciled in the possibilities for you like a teaching assistant explaining the Laffer Curve to a class of freshman economics students.  At one point in the broadcast they showed one of the leaders in the clubhouse thumbing through an app on his iPhone-clearly this was the only way he was going to know where he stood in the proceedings. There is something wrong when the players and the fans need a seeing eye dog and an MIT professor to update them on the current status of a golf tournament.

Bottom line is that if they want to create a real sense of riveting anticipation they need to end the bifurcation of the results of the final tournament and the year long competition.  Fans and players cannot comprehend a parallel competition in real time.

After much musing  and deliberation, my number crunching cohort R.M. and I have come up with the solution.  It is really simple,  we need March Madness in September.  Four tournaments make up the playoffs.  In sequence the first two tournaments winnow the fields from 125 to 60 and 60 to 30 respectively.   The third tournament takes it from 30 to 4, the “Final Fore”, who play for the whole FedEx enchilada the last week.

This FedEx Championship event would be an innovative affair where the four guys play each other for three days in variety of formats for travel money and caddy fees to get it down to two finalists.  The two still standing play on Sunday a three point Nassau, with presses, for the $10 million-winner takes all.  Now that could be the back nine at Augusta every year.

September, 2011