Postcard From Old Macdonald-Day 3

Old Macdonald is “an homage to the vision and spirit of C.B. Macdonald” the grandfather of American golf architects.  Tom Doak provides us with a laboratory experience of the concepts and features of links golf on a sprawling piece of glorious links land.  It lacks the overwelming character of Bandon Dunes or Pacific Dunes but for those who pay attention it contains all the mysterious subtle quirks that make links golf so intriguing.

Get a sense of the ethereal expanse on which Old Mac sits.

Sprawling holes set against dramatic walls of gorse.

Holes wend through sand, scrub, and gorse.

The ghost Port Orford Cedar haunts a blind drive over the dune.

Hell Bunker….no Purgatory from there.

Nor much from the Road Hole bunker.

He sat, he refreshed, he plodded on.

Biarritz Par Three-that channel in the green is 3 feet deep.

Peek-a-boo approach.

Design features are oversized….even the sky.

Often difficult to discern where the fairway ends and green begins.

Commander Owl still trying to figure it out.

Now that is a bunker….a WW I bunker without the troops.

Doak Sand Game Improvement Center between holes.

August, 2012

(Click to read Postcard From Pacific Dunes-Day 4)

For more course detail click to see Old Macdonald Course Review

Postcard From Bandon Preserve-Day 2

Part II of Coore-Crenshaw Day was a lovely stroll of the 13-hole, yes 13 holes, Bandon Preserve Par 3 Links Course.  All the links elements-dunes, fierce bunkers, wild greens, and, of course, the wind.  No designated tees but plenty of options on each hole to pick from.

The holes…pick the tee of your liking…lots of variety in each hole

It is a perfect place to let your hair down, unwind, and settle a few bets.  Bandon Preserve is a real diamond in the rough.  With short tracks like these in every town in America golf would be enjoyed by many, many more folks.

The Motley Crew up for the Srixon Neon Challenge


(Click on any picture to get an enhanced view of the image)

All the elements of a links hole…just shorter.

Sherpa guides point the way.

Assessing the scene of the crime.

Hide and seek on the flag.

Wind swept?

Big friendly groupings, a few bets, and some adult beverages.

A little Jack happiness.

And there is the ocean.

#13 the final stop.

August, 2012

(Click to read Postcard From Old Macdonald-Day 3)

Postcard From Bandon Trails-Day 2

Today was Coore-Crenshaw Day for the Motley’s as we ventured to this stunning Pine Barrens accented creation on the rugged hills and sand dunes of Bandon.  The course meanders through sandy dunes, green meadows, and pine forests getting it’s unique character from the blend of these environments.  Coore-Crenshaw integrated links elements like blowout bunkers, nasty gorse, and natural green settings with the challenge of dramatically mounded fairways and mind boggling elevation changes to create a golf challenge with a racing pulse.

Stone Monuments In Bandon Lodge       (photo courtesy of M. Levine)
Our days begin with a ritual incantation touching the stones and praying for pars and birdies.

On this glorious day the popcorn sky over the tree tops that frame every hole.

Pine Barren look mixed with links random bunkering demands clear decision making.

Dramatic elevation change, fierce bunkering, and a three story green challenge.

Matriculation Benches-chance to catch a breath and ponder your fate.

Natural Green Settings-they just extracted the terrarium features to surround them with bother.

Huge Elevation Changes-make club and shot selection a real challenge.

Plodding down the trail down to the landing area with the drift wood fencing marking
the way.

Stump Flower Pot-exhibits indigenous vegetation that defines the environment of this course.

Arduous march toward home up a six story par five.


The Full Monty-one last par three with everything but the kitchen sink.

August, 2012

(Click to read Postcard From Bandon Preserve-Day 2)

For more course detail click to see Bandon Trails Course Review

Postcard From Bandon Dunes-Day 1

First impressions of Bandon Dunes on a sunny and windy day on the Oregon coast.  An authentic walking links without pretension.  Bandon encompasses the complete natural look and feel of the coastal elements with a touch of wind to add some uncertainty.  Plenty of unexpected bounces to accept and unrelenting hazards to avoid.  Links golf is about acceptance, patience, and perseverance.  For a links afficianados, Bandon Dunes is the real deal.


The Clubhouse-staging and viewing area

Practice Center-Shorty’s Signal-this side of the range is closed today.

The Jaw Dropping Vistas

Pretty As A Painting-with all the seaside elements-furry mounds, sod-wall bunker, sea grass, and wind exposure.

Still Life With Rake

Drift Wood-from Hawaii?

Dwarf pines and gorse accent the links.

Misdirection-How do you get to this flag on ten?

Simple Challenge-avoid the pot and hold it on the table top….and account for the wind influence.

A Reflective Shade Tree Moment

An Environmental Forced Carry-then negotiate the roller coaster green.

The Finish

The Motley Crew
Justin, Moe, Kathy, Marla, Alan, and Dave

August, 2012

(Click to read Postcard From Bandon Trails-Day 2)

For more course detail click to see Bandon Dunes Course Review

Grounds For Golf

This book is subtitled “The History and Fundamentals of Golf Course Design” and that is an accurate description of what it is about.  Fundamentals, not the wonky details, of course design is what Shackelford successfully relates to the arm chair course architects out there.

You know who you are.  Guys who regularly are moving bunkers or rerouting the front and back nine on their home courses over clam chowder after an above handicap performance and a loss of two out of three on the morning Nassaus.  Or guys who come back from that man trip with a litany of “suggestions” on how those name brand architects could have made the courses just a tinch more playable.

This is an informative and very readable primer on golf course design and the history that has brought us to where we are today.  Shackelford is a bright guy with an easy going writing style who is well briefed in the subject and opinionated enough to make it thought provoking.  He is a guy who has played all the holes he discusses and has done the necessary background research as well.  The book is full of thoughtful quotes from C.B. Macdonald, Alister MacKenzie, Ben Crenshaw, Tom Doak, Pete and Alice Dye, among other design authorities that lend credibility to his opinions on the history of the development of course design.

For example:

“We want our golf courses to make us think.  However much we may enjoy whaling the life out of the little white ball, we soon grow tired of play a golf course that does not give us problems in strategy as well as skill.”
Bobby Jones

Add to this the etchings of Gil Hanse, a fine course designer in his own right, and it is a well presented and balanced presentation on a subject that too often is discussed vociferously without adequate background knowledge.

The book is compartmentalized by subject to cover what is architecture, schools of design, evolution of the craft, principles of design, great holes and classic designs, and even the nomenclature of the industry.  His two chapters on Comic Relief in quality design and the role of Temptation as a key element in challenging players to make quality decisions that will affect their scorecards are particularly interesting.

Shackelford has the distinction of having dabbled in design as a consultant on a track not far from Los Angeles called Rustic Canyon that he did under the tutelage of Gil Hanse and Jim Wagner.  This is a natural looking daily fee course they created in the rugged foothills of Southern California and it avails him the opportunity to explain many of his theories of design as expressed through their own experience in creating this course.

The print version is accessible for a steep price in the used market but you can get the Nook electronic version for about $7.99 through the internet.

This book is not for everyone, you need a bias of interest in the topic to wade through the detail he presents.  If you are an armchair architecture wonk like me this is something you need to have read if for no other reason than to have some basis for your personal authority when criticizing the Pete Dye design that just ate your lunch.

Grounds For Golf

Geoff Shackelford (2003)

Mindset For Golf

Excessive golfing dwarfs the intellect.  Nor is this to be wondered at when we consider that the more fatuously vacant the mind is, the better for play…Next to the idiotic, the dull unimaginative mind is the best for golf.

Sir Walter Simpson

The Art of Golf (1887)

Quoted in: Grounds For Golf

Geoff Shackelford (2003)

Bringing A Smile To The Game

The indelible image Rory brings to winning these major championships in a rout is a huge smile, something fans find incredibly endearing and fun to root for.  His eight-shot victory in the PGA Championship at Kiawah this weekend makes him a “multiple major winner”, number one in the world golf ranking, and a shoe-in to dominate all golf discussion from now through the Ryder Cup.

Jim Nance said at the end of the broadcast that when Rory won the U.S. Open by 8 furlongs at Congressional last summer it brought a smile to the game.  Well if that was a smile then this time it is a Cheshire grin.  He was 11-under over the last 36 holes and completely dominated the best field of the year on a course that was borderline psychotic.  And this was the second time he orchestrated this scenario in a major in the last 14 months.

The fact is that he is just 23 years old and joins a very short list of Jack, Seve, and Tiger who have won two majors at such an early age.  He shares with these guys the rare ability, in the heat of a major championship, to hyper focus his attention, block out the distractions that are derailing the competition, and let the gift of his talents produce play that separates him from the field.

What ingratiates him to the viewing public is the unfettered joy he brings to the arena. In contrast to the other guy who wears the red shirt on Sunday and seems to want to strangle a rattlesnake in the process, Rory has a sublime sense of calm as he is disarming the golf course and the field of competitors in pursuit.  He has a respectful demeanor to his adversaries and an outward appreciation for the adulation of the fans who acknowledge his accomplishments.

In the post game interviews he shows equal measure of confidence in his ability and humility for what it all really means.  When his accomplishments are compared to Jack or Tiger his response is that he is flattered by such comparisons but he feels he has a long way to go before justifying such associations.

He is also cognizant of the fact that his accomplishments make him a role model to thousands of kids around the world who look up to him as the new wunderkind.   Instead of seeing this as a burden he says he sees it as an honor and something he keeps in mind as he comports himself every day pursuing his craft.

Anyone who saw his performance this weekend can only be in awe of his ability to compose his talents with such grace under pressure.  It is just possible that time and accumulated accomplishments will put him in the category of the greats who have ever played the game.  For now we will have to accept that this very bright star is illuminating the golf horizon, there for all of us to gaze on in wonder and thoroughly enjoy.

August, 2012

That _______ Dye!

As is always the case when a professional golf event is being contested on a Pete Dye course, it is as much as much a matter of the players versus Dye as the players against the field.  You can fill in the blank yourself because the possibilities are endless as to what will come off of their lips as they head to the courtesy cars each day at this year’s PGA Championship at The Ocean Course at Kiawah Island.

The PGA at Whistling Straits in 2010, The Players every year at Sawgrass, the Women’s U.S. Open at Blackwolf this year…just to mention a few…..the list goes on and on.  In all cases it is more than simply a test of golf…..it is the challenge to survive and avoid personal humiliation.  In Pete’s view he would have it no other way. His job is to baffle the best players in the game with big challenges, lots of strategic choices, and punitive results if they don’t pass muster.

This should only be their biggest danger of the day (photo: flicker.Adammart)

The Ocean Course may be the sternest test of them all.  When Pete and Alice built this course on the sandy shores of South Carolina it was not enough just to route the holes along the ocean between the sand dunes. They actually raised the center of the property to make sure the interior holes would have full view of the ocean and full exposure to the ocean breezes.  Add to this their ingenious eye for fashioning real risk and reward holes and this event adds up to a demolition derby in Footjoys.

The course was first built to host the infamous “War By The Shore” version of the 1991 Ryder Cup which brought enmity between the sides to new heights.  As you will recall it wreaked it’s share of psychological havoc on a number of highly successful professionals of the day.  They could put a Memorial Wall beside the 17th green to commemorate all the rounds that been drowned over the years trying to negotiate that tee shot.  Personally, I think it is a hard par from the drop area.

Pete has since been back a number times to tweak the layout in preparation for the 2007 Senior PGA and once again for this championship.  It certainly has not gotten any easier as a result.

The Dye’s are the masters of deception when it comes to hiding their intent on a given hole.  The Ocean Course is full of this. Fairways that are much more generous than they seem from the tee.  Landing areas confined by fall offs to nastiness that you cannot discern from 220 yards away.  Undulating table top greens that feed off to seas of undulation six feet below the putting surface.  Add to this adjacent waste areas the size of small neighborhoods in Newark (and not a whole lot safer I might add), plenty of native grasses on sandy dunes, and a good measure of marshland from which, as the sign says, you are wise not to even consider trying to retrieve your ball.

Pete has gone so far as to introduce a mysterious new grass-Paspalum-in the green complexes that the pros have never played on.  This stuff has a sticky character that will arrest the progress of a rolling ball and make using the bump and run recovery up the side banks of these platform greens a very low percentage shot.  Tiger, among others, has expressed that given the number of times you get short sided on a wind blown approach managing this grass will be a significant factor in keeping your scorecard in tact.

Adam Scott in an interview early in the week gave a blunt assessment when asked his impression of the course, “The front nine is a really nice, playable golf course, and then the back nine is not.”

Typically the PGA set ups lead to a score of about 10 under plus or minus a few blows, but this year it will totally depend on the weather.  The course has been softened considerably by rain almost every day.  Good news is that the greens will be holding.  Bad news is the course, which can be played at 7700 yards, could play very long.  Besides the obvious issues of thunderstorms interrupting play, there are generally strong winds associated with these low pressure systems.  The wind will be the major factor in determining whether these guys can hit the precise shots required to negotiate this house of mirrors.

The post round interviews should be very entertaining indeed.

August, 2012

The Ocean Course-Kiawah Island

Simply put this is Dante’s Inferno above ground.  Pete Dye has tried and succeeded in producing the most diabolical compilation of golf holes he could conceive with the sole purpose being to humiliate the pros and mere mortals alike.  It is safe to say that this course is truly unfair, almost unplayable, and just not alot of fun.  It would be better to buy the 1991 Ryder Cup tape on video and enjoy the train wrecks from the comfort of your own home.

Not so much a real test of golf-it is more like an inquisition-meant to break your spirit and mind and  bring you to your knees.  It amply achieves all of this by the fifth tee.  You will notice by the time you are done that all the people in front of you and behind you are trudging slowly like lemmings through the waste areas, head down, shoulders slumped, resigned to their sentence in this demonic golf hell.  This is not an experience for the faint of heart.

The course is routed in an S-hook shape which means the first four and last five holes are in the same wind direction and the middle nine are in the opposite direction.  The problem here is that if the middle nine are all upwind you will need a medvac helicopter by the fourteenth tee.  Since the entire track is totally exposed to the ocean you will get ferocious winds on days that are calm back at the condo.  Determining required distance and club selection are a major problem all day long.  You can get real tired of hitting your 3-wood 175 into the prevailing breeze.

Pete and Alice pulled out all the stops on this one.  You have your massive waste areas like TPC Sawgrass, your signature Dye railroad ties hardening the edges of the hazards, and Alice even raised the fairways on the inland leg of holes adjacent to the ocean to make sure you get the full brunt of the wind effect all day.  Much like his other “made to humiliate the pros” tracks at Sawgrass and PGA West, this one is pure punitive target golf.  Every tee shot or shot at a green is a forced carry or to a confined arrangement that has a penalty shot or an impossible recovery tied to your lack of success.  Some of the adjacent waste areas run the entire length of the hole-and most are from five to eight feet below the playing area-making your extrication from same seriously problematic.  Nothing is “kept” here-it is all raw and natural-that presents a beautiful esthetic background to enjoy if you were not in such physical and emotional agony.

Stunning beauty of the long awaited finish at 18 (pga.com)

I have great respect for Pete Dye as an innovative designer who successfully broke the mold of his predecessors Robert Trent Jones and Dick Wilson of designing long, boring heroic courses.  But Pete might have slipped over the edge on this one.  There are interesting tactical elements with risk/reward decisions attached but the ever presence of stiff Atlantic breezes make it far too punitive to enjoy.  As a result, it seems to me that he ended up with a course that is nothing but a scenic and perverse marketing ploy meant to attract the “grip it and rip it” crowd in the golf demographic.

Kiawah Island, South Carolina

Architect: Pete Dye (1991)

Tee                 Par     Rating     Slope    Yardage
Tournament    72       77.2        144       7356
Ocean            72       73.6        138       6779
Dye                72       72           134       6475

(Click here to review Ocean Course hole-by-hole descriptions)

Objects May Be Closer Than They Appear

Like the cyclists in the velodrome at the London Olympics, Keegan Bradley drafted the back nine in the wake of Jim Furyk’s apparent wire-to-wire victory pace passing him on the last leg on the way to a 64 and a stunning come from behind victory in the WGC Bridgestone Invitational.

Playing in the final group with Jim Furyk who set a torrid pace with birdies on the first three holes on Sunday, Keegan just kept himself within sight of the leader until they turned the back nine.  Starting with two birdies on the back and a scrambling par on 12 Keegan had that look in his eye that he was not going to be shaken off the leader’s pace.

The key moment was probably at the 16th hole. Louis Oosthuizen who was two back at the time pulled the Tiger Woods Houdini flop shot from the spinach behind the green to make an unlikely birdie and get within one of Furyk.  Furyk playing with the confidence that had built his the lead through 69 holes would not be outdone, he make a 25-footer of his own for birdie to maintain his position.  Keegan then made a statement, making a 15-footer on top of Furyk to stay within striking distance one back.

With a one-shot lead, apparently Furyk failed to heed the warning message screened on his side view mirror coming down eighteen. When they both failed to hit the green in regulation it was Keegan who made a miraculous up and down par from a plugged lie in the green side bunker and Furyk who blinked taking two shots from off the green to get on and two more putts on the way to a disappointing double bogie and a two-shot swing.

As we saw with Keegan at last year’s PGA, this young guy has a knack for making big putts.  He was first or second in all three of the putting stats this week averaging just 26 putts a round over the four days.  As to the final 15-foot par putt that forged him into the lead he said, “I didn’t think for a second I was going to miss it….I knew exactly how it was going to break….I just needed to hit it hard enough….and it was dead center”.

Steve Stricker played some outstanding golf himself shooting 64 on Sunday.  Putting like the Stricker of old he birdied four of the last five holes in a final sprint that grabbed a share of second place.

With only the PGA Championship next week between them and the eight automatic Ryder Cup Team assignments, Keegan consolidated his grip on a valued position moving from 9th to 4th on the list.   Both Stricker (moving from 13th to 10th) and Furyk (moving from 15th to 11th) have positioned themselves for a final push next week.  Finishing outside the top 15 this week, Rickie Fowler, Brandt Snedeker, and Dustin Johnson all have serious work to do if they want to avoid begging for a captain’s choice.

The FedEx Cup Playoffs with a pot of gold at the end of the rainbow are less than a month away.  Serious jockeying for improved position in that race is going on and Furyk and Stricker both  moved up significantly to get into the top 16.  Keegan made the biggest move of all from 26th to 7th after today’s win.  There will be a whole lot of listening for footsteps behind them as this qualifying race heads down the final stretch.

August, 2012