James Finegan: Voice of the Links

Your relationship with James Finegan probably started like mine. Back from a first trip to Ireland, talking with friends about the experience and chomping at the bit to get back for more, someone who had been to the British Isles a second time says, “Then you got to read Finegan”.

What ensued was typical…off to Barnes and Noble, fingering through a copy of “Emerald Fairways and Foam Flecked Seas-A Golfer’s Pilgrimage to the Courses of Ireland” I am drawn in by personal accounts of places I had played-Ballybunion, Rosses Point, and Royal County Down. Finegan’s visual of RCD is typical, “What strikes us-in truth, assaults us-are the massive sand hills, the profusion of gorse (overpoweringly golden in spring, impenetrable at any time) and the heady views”.

Once owned the romance with his writing accelerated as he described courses large and small, quaint hotels and B & B’s, town histories and antiquities, and his experiences with the locals. He captured the lure of Ireland through this descriptive of a chance encounter with an Irish immigrant-that is to say a Philadelphian who had moved to Dublin.

“This free spirit fascinated us. The very notion of simply picking up and going to Ireland to live because the golf was ideal-well, this was so preposterously at variance with such things as discipline and roots….it was dizzying to contemplate….Think of it: a golf expatriate, an expatriate not because of taxes or career or love but for golf. I had to concede that it was not a noble rationale for self-exile. Nor was it ignoble.”

Whether it was this one or “Blasted Heaths and Blessed Greens” about Scotland or a third about England and Wales, or his seminal collection “Scotland-Where Golf Is Great” becoming a James Finegan fan just happens. The rapture of his prose, his unique voice on links golf, makes recalling your last trip or planning your next one a vibrant and exhilarating experience.

James W. Finegan passed away this week in his hometown of Philadelphia at the age of 85. You can read Michael Bamberger’s stirring tribute to “another member of golf’s greatest generation…an extraordinary voice in the game, both as a speaker and writer”. Bamberger says, “Alongside Herbert Warren Wind, no other American writer captured the windblown, rugged beauty of golf in the British Isles with such wild enthusiasm”.

The true fans of the game have lost a chronicler, a scribe of all that is good and great about links golf. Thankfully Finegan’s links voice will continue to influence the itineraries of golfing pilgrims for generations to come through the cherished impressions he has left with us.

.
(Click to read Michael Bamberger’s tribute to James Finegan on Golf.com)

March, 2015

 

Protect The Practice Grounds

A reminder from the guys @College_Golfers….whether you are grinding away with your mid-irons on the range or refining your finesse pitching at the short game area you want to minimize your divot footprint by following the straight line practice protocol on the left.

Proper Range Divots

For each subsequent shot place your ball one inch behind your previous divot. It will eliminate divot scatter and make a huge difference to the long term maintenance of your practice grounds.

College Golf@College_Golfers

March, 2015

Throwing Caution To The Wind

In case you missed it on Friday Rory McIlroy, the current #1 in the World Golf Rankings, let his temper get the best of him on the 8th at Doral after hitting his 3-iron approach into the drink and flung the disobedient implement a good 75 yards into the water next to him.

Rory wasn’t entirely enamored with his play on Friday at Doral

Embed from Getty Images

.

To his own admission, it wasn’t his proudest moment, but it felt good at the time. Henrik Stenson, his playing pard and a man known to display a personal anger tempest from time-to-time said, “Well, if you can’t get on ‘SportsCenter with your play, at least you can do it with something else”.

As far as being a bad role model with this show of temper, let the record show it did not take very long. Marcel Siem, a fellow European Tour stand out, replicated the act on Saturday after stuffing his long iron in a green side bunker on the same hole. Rory may have to anchor a public relations campaign against helicoptering long irons to tamp down a brush fire among young Rory-ites..

Take a look at Bob Harig’s ESPN.com article on the affair which includes full video of the fling as well as Rory’s version of contrition in his post game press conference on Friday.

BTW, as Bobby Knight, a man who knows from where this comes, said in his interview with David Feherty a while back when asked about the proper form for flinging metal objects, it is all about getting to your left side on the follow through. You will note that the true athlete in Rory came through in his fling form, there is not a hint of a duck hook in the flight of the iron.

Good news is a diver was back in the pond yesterday to retrieve the club and it seems to have survived the swim with it’s dignity in tact. Only question is whether this 3-iron now shows up on EBay or in a glass case at Doral for the sake of recollection.

.
(Click to read Bob Harig’s article about Rory’s Frustrated Fling)

March, 2015

Golf Rules Illustrated

Golf Rules IllustratedThe USGA publications tend to be dry, button-down, corporate presentations that are about as much fun to read as the obituary columns in your local paper.  But they stepped out of their blue blazer mode in the publication of Golf Rules Illustrated 2012-2015-The Official Illustrated Guide To the Rules of Golf.

Every one who plays the game is confronted with rules conundrums whether it is from their Saturday group, an outing they are playing, or the live action they are watching during the Sunday tournament broadcast.  The first person they are likely to ask is the head pro at their place and the second person is probably a single digit guy they barely know walking through the locker room.  More often than not they come away more confused about the rules then when they posed the question.

Sure there are on-line sources like Barry Rhodes Rules School who is probably the reigning authority outside of the USGA/R & A tandem when it comes to answering rules questions.  You could check resources like our Keepers Rules Education Initiative which explains frequently asked rules incidents with on course scenarios to clarify the nuances of rules in your day-to-day game.

But for coherent answers to all golf rule questions you need only have a copy of the Golf Rules Illustrated book at your disposal to get meat of the matter in a hurry.  The book is organized with color-coded index for each chapter that covers one the 34 rules in the game.  For each rule and it includes an explanation of the rule and it’s related sub-cases with a combination of easy to understand text, simple illustrations, relevant photos, and real incidents and frequently asked questions.

A simple visual explains what you are prohibited from doing in a bunker

Ball In Bunker Prohibited ActionThe table of contents makes it easy to find what you are looking for and once there you will find yourself perusing the related sub-cases as well as real incidents from the tour that will bring the rules to life for you.  The FAQs help to fill in the gaps so you reconcile the obvious questions that come to mind as you start to understand the rule at hand.

Let’s say you need to know if the pile of rabbit poop your ball landed in can be removed without penalty as Loose Impediments (Rule 23).

This illustration defines Loose Impediments vs Movable Obstructions

Loose ImpedimentsYou recall that crazy situation when Tiger got to move a boulder in Arizona, a loose impediment in his way that took an army of people to remove.  Check the incident section of Rule 23 for an account of that crazy affair and the logic that supported the ruling.

Embed from Getty Images

.

It then occurs to you, can you remove sand on the putting even though your ball lies off the putting surface….check the Frequently Asked Questions at the end of the chapter.

Maybe you were playing with your buddies the other day and one of them hit a ball off a steep upslope that came straight up and deflected off this body.  Any penalty for that?

Happened to Jeff Maggert at the 2003 Masters and cost him a one-stroke penalty

Ball Hitting A PlayerBut this leads you to wonder about other incidents where a ball is stopped or deflected by hitting your opponents bag or another ball in motion.

Ball In Motion DeflectedDropping the ball whether for free relief or in implementing a penalty can lead to all kinds of variations of events.  In the chapter on Rule 20-Lifting, Dropping and Placing-it clearly explains a litany of scenarios including cases when you must re-drop.

RedroppingUnder the FAQ they address whether a player is required to mark the position of a ball he is going to drop before lifting it.

Remember Van de Velde’s choosing this option from the water hazard at the Open

Embed from Getty Images

.

This book is an invaluable reference for getting the rules right because it cuts through all the legal language to present an intelligible understanding of the rules and related issues as well as providing simple visuals to reinforce the logic of how the rules must be implemented.

For about 15 bucks you can get this from any number of the on-line book purveyors. Golf Rules Illustrated should have a front row spot on your golf library shelf.  The pages will become dog-eared in no time.

(Illustrations and photos from Golf Rules Illustrated 2012-2015)

February, 2015

moerate4

Best Down Under

ISPS Australian Open LogoLydia Ko at 17 years old became the youngest player to reach the #1 ranking on the LPGA Tour a few weeks ago with a second place finish in the Coates Golf Championship. If anyone had doubts about her credentials at such a young age they were put to bed with an impressive win today of ISPS Handa Australian Open at Royal Melbourne.

Lydia’s Aimpoint putting technique emphasizes her ranking

Embed from Getty Images

.

Royal Melbourne is a true championship test that has befuddled professionals of both genders with it’s Alister MacKenzie green complexes. This week was no exception as the hot Australian summer presented parched hard and fast fairways and greens stimping a major championship speeds. Lydia played with metronomic patience on the composite par 73 layout with scores of 70-70-72-71 to win at 9-under par.

This was Lydia’s 8th professional win on the LPGA and European Ladies and caps off a 14 month period where she has won 4 times with 18 top 10 finishes in 29 events. She has not missed a cut and won $2,400,00 over that span.

The stretch began with a gripping toe-to-toe 1 shot victory over Stacey Lewis in the Swinging Skirts LPGA Classic at Lake Merced last April. Lydia then added the Marathon Classic in July with a 1 stroke win over So Yeon Ryu. Then she put herself seriously in the #1 ranking mix with a playoff win at the CME Group Tour Championship in November. The only thing missing from her trophy case is a piece of major championship hardware and that cannot be far away.

Since she splashed on the scene with her first LPGA Tour victory as an amateur at age 14 in the CN Canadian Women’s Open Lydia has shown a mature approach to playing that belies her years. Her game resembles the consistency of Annika Sorenstam in her peak years. Lydia has hit 85% of the fairways this year and this week on a Royal Melbourne course with serious fire in it’s belly she has consistently hit 89% of the greens each day.

Ko’s proficiency with hybrids reminds us of Annika’s Callaway Metal Wood Game

Embed from Getty Images

.
The final day began with Lydia tied for the lead at 7-under with Ariya Jutanugarn and Amy Yang one back at 6-under. It pretty much became a head-to-head competition between Ko and Yang as the rest of the field faded fairly early in the front nine.

Ko asserted herself with an amazing pitch in on the third hole for eagle to take the lead outright at 8-under. She was on cruise control with four straight pars until she hit an approach pitch into the 8th green two steps past the flag only to see the hand of Alister shuttle it off the back of this devious green complex and end up 30 yards over the green in a thatchy lie with an impossible elevator pitch back up to the flag. The unforced error cost her a bogie and a two-shot swing tied them at the top when Yang buried a 50-footer on the 9th hole in front of her.

The momentum further shifted in Yang’s direction when she laced her second shot on the par 5 10th to inside 15 feet for a good eagle opportunity. But the golf goddesses interceded as the storm alarm sounded before she could putt forcing an interruption in play that stifled her charge. After play resumed she missed the eagle putt settling for a birdie which Lydia matched on the 10th to bring them both to 8-under.

Lydia asserted herself again with a good birdie opportunity on the 11th but left the putt in the jaws and settle for par. On the par 4 12th she hit it to 25 feet and calmly rolled in a curling birdie putt to regain the lead alone at 9-under.

When the birdie putt found bottom on the 12th the Fat Lady was humming

Embed from Getty Images

.

Yang, just one back on the par 5 14th, hit her second into the green side bunker and made a gutsy up and down for birdie to once again tie the lead at 9-under. But her putter was to be her undoing as she missed a short one on 15 to make bogey failing to get up and down from in front of the green. A miscue on 17 led to another bogey and her final second place position at 7-under par.

From the 13th tee to the trophy presentation it was fairway and greens for Lydia without a dropped shot on the card as she proved once again to be a stoic front runner once she has the lead.  This performance was hauntingly similar to her win over Stacy Lewis at Lake Merced.

These victory speeches are becoming old hat for Lydia

Embed from Getty Images

.
At 17 this young woman is maturing quickly shedding the Annie Hall spectacles for contact lenses, embracing make-up, and wearing more stylish attire. The new look still has a ways to go to catch up with the maturity of her golf game which has gotten her to #1 and will make it a formidable task for anyone to dislodge Lydia from that perch.

February, 2015

Does Tiger Have The Yips?

I don’t think so. Nor do a number of other folks with serious golf smarts including Tour Putting Guru Marius Filmalter.

Of late these short pitches have spawned more frowns than smiles

Embed from Getty Images

.

Check out Marius’s recent article on golf.com where he clearly believe’s Tiger’s short game problems are not neurological but a matter of proper technique confidently applied. He should know since his client list includes a who’s who of top global players from the PGA, European, L.P.G.A and Champion’s tours.

I for one think Marius has it right. In spite of his pathetic short game performances at the Hero’s Challenge In December and the Waste Management and Farmer’s more recently there is really nothing in his short game that resembles the yips to me. Tiger has simply lost his way on short swing technique. But the question is why?

For me the answer lies in Tiger’s unrealistic quest for golf perfection. He not only wants be the best player the game has ever seen but he wants to have the perfect golf swing as well. Throughout the early part of his career he repeatedly said he wanted to “own his swing” in a Hogan-like sense. For a guy who pretty much had the perfect swing back in 2000 under the tutelage of B.H. he has repeatedly wandered from expert to expert in search of something more perfect. The bad news is that the more he has tried to refine his swing the further from the truth he has found himself.

I buy the fact that as he says, his current short game performance problems are because he cannot synchronize his new little swing pattern to bottom out properly. But the question is why try? It may be inherent that a player’s big swing and little swing tend to look alike but it does not have to be that way.

As Phil said in comments about Tiger’s pitching woes, “There’s only one way to chip effectively. So regardless of how you swing the club, regardless of how you putt, there’s only one way to chip, because the leading edge on a 60-degree wedge is coming into the ball first. And everything you do chipping is to get, keep the leading edge down. So there’s three or four fundamentals on chipping that everybody has to do to chip well. No matter who you are. And it has nothing to do with your swing.”

He needs to forget about synchronizing methods of his long and short swings and focus on the fundamentals of quality short game shots that are the same for all players, regardless of swing principles.

Tiger’s never ending quest to reinvent his big swing to meet his latest sense of perfection has leaked into what was the best short game on tour and wreaked havoc. Marius is correct when he says Tiger needs to get back to fundamental sound technique around the greens and harmonize it with the self awareness that he is doing it properly.

It is time for Tiger to stop soliciting the advice of any tour player within earshot and listen to the familiar voice of a short game expert he knows. If he brings this short game to Augusta, the most demanding tight lie short game shot course in the world, he will not break 80.

(Click to read the Marius Filmalter article “Tiger Woods Does Not Have The Yips”)

February, 2015

Bib Bondage

PGA Tour caddies filed a class-action lawsuit claiming they are sick of being unpaid sandwich sign board shills for the corporate sponsors of PGA Tour events. The caddies at tour events are required to wear the logo-covered bibs which bear the tournament sponsor’s moniker and are paid nothing in endorsement fees for this powerful marketing effort each week.

For months the caddies have been attempting to negotiate a deal with the PGA Tour that in lieu of being paid for this the tour would contribute money to a retirement and health insurance fund for the benefit of the caddies. Those talks broke down hence the filing of this lawsuit followed.

The tour sucks gazillions of bucks out of big corporate sponsors like Waste Management, Farmer’s Insurance, and A T & T for sponsoring PGA Tour stops. The signage for the sponsoring corporation is everywhere-in ads, on tickets, programs, placard signs around the course, and on the bibs of the 125 to 140 caddies that walk across TV screens with the players each week.

The only one seeing green from this each week is the PGA Tour

Embed from Getty Images

.
Considering that these events are covered for nationwide broadcast audience on the Golf Channel on Thursday and Friday and then the networks on Saturday and Sunday that is a lot of eyeball time for selling product. Every time the leading players commiserate with their caddies over club selection or putting line it is another 20 to 30 seconds of uninterrupted exposure of the sponsor’s corporate logo. What do the caddies get remunerated for their invaluable role in this marketing exposure ….bupkis ….nada …zilch….apparently not even a thank you.

In our area retail merchants are often prohibited by local governments from putting temporary advertising signs on the curbs in front of their stores. So they resort to hiring people with sandwich board signs across their shoulders to walk the highway median strips to do their marketing bidding instead. Apparently this kind of expression tied to a person has first amendment free speech protection along with monetary compensation.

Tim Finchem’s reaction to the suggestion that the tour should share the spoils of this marketing arrangement with the caddies, “Most people don’t understand the way a caddie/player relationship works…it goes back a long way. The player makes an arrangement with somebody to carry their bag …..and they work out a financial arrangement …..the historical process is the player handles that.”

He did explain that in spite of the fact that the Tour’s policy has been to never negotiate compensation with caddies, the tour does currently give caddies a $2,000 annual stipend for health insurance. Sounds like he is talking out of both sides of his mouth to me.

Tim has a seven figure salary, a Bentley of a benefits package, and a golden parachute to boot so he is probably not aware that $2,000 a year does not buy very much in the Affordable Health Care Market today. $166.67 a month is not buying a PPO Insurance Plan with major medical coverage for your dependents. Given how much time these guys spend out in the sun they probably need a melanoma rider that would cost that much.

Displeasure with this free marketing labor arrangement on the tour is not recent. Steve Williams, the caddie for a decade plus for Eldrick Woods, used to pull off his bib and ball it up in his fist as soon as Tiger’s putt crossed the lip of the final hole. For all the winning that Tiger did on Steve’s watch Williams became one of the most highly paid sports figures in his home country of New Zealand. But even he sensed he was not getting his fair share of the weekly entertainment take and was adamant about expressing that displeasure.

Most of the caddies on tour barely make enough to make ends meet, not many are going into early retirement to live off of their stock portfolios. It seems only fair that since they are such an ever present element of the presentation of golf on TV they too should get some benefit from being an accessory to marketing the product.

.
February, 2015

PGA Merchandise Show 2015

PGA Merch Show 2015 LogoEvery year this time about 1000 plus exhibitors set up in over 400,000 square feet of exhibition space at the Orange Country Convention Center in Orlando to put on the biggest golf trade show of the year. The exhibitors include Titleist, TaylorMade, Ping, Club Car, Peter Millar, Ralph Lauren Golf, Footjoy, Ecco and everyone in between. It is a smorgasbord of equipment, clothing, shoes, performance drinks, fancy golf carts, swing improvement contraptions, portable swing analysis apps, indoor putting surfaces, and so much more.

PGA Mechandise ShowThe week begins Tuesday with Demo Day sprawling across the wrap around practice range at Orange County National. This is like a lawn party of new equipment offerings and swing clinics.

Demo Day Sign

Feels like a circus....

Feels like a circus….without elephants…plenty of clowns though.

Demo stations for every brand...every new offering.

Demo stations for every brand…every new offering.

Including the latest sales pitch.

Including the latest sales pitch.

Some tips from short game guru Dave Pelz.

Some tips from short game guru Dave Pelz.

A little pick-me-up late in the day?

A little pick-me-up late in the day?

(All Demo Day photos provided by our Cub Reporter on the scene A. Blitz)

Wednesday through Friday the exposition moves to the convention center in town. We were among legions of people pouring through the aisles every day. For the retailers of golf merchandise this is a major work week, for those lucky enough to tag along and just peek in the show window it is a giddy week of wonder.

Latest technology does not pass notice.

Latest on course technology does not pass notice.

Name brand folk are there…big and small….some of their digs look more like retail stores than exposition booths

You might as well be shopping at Nordstroms.

You might as well be shopping at Nordstroms.

Go right from the putting green to the croquet green.

Go right from the putting green to the croquet green.

Way more than just shoes...

Way more than just shoes…

Golf and lifestyle.....all at one stop.

Golf and lifestyle…..all at one stop.

Latest product offerings…..

Ecco suede wing tips....for guys and gals.

Ecco suede wing tips….for guys and gals.

These pants, shorts, and skirts speak volumes.

These Loudmouth pants, shorts, and skirts speak volumes.

Creative Covers have licensed and original characters.

Creative Covers have licensed and original characters.

T.M.N.T. Donatello up close and personal.

T.M.N.T. Donatello up close and personal.

New Superstroke Grips counter-balance weighted version.

New Superstroke Grips counter-balance weighted version.

Ogio "freezes" that iron clicking sound out of your bag.

Ogio “freezes” that iron clicking sound out of your bag.

Then there are the niche items…….

Hanging ten...how about this for your next nine.

Hanging ten…how about this for your next nine.

A golf bedtime story...you can never start them too young.

A golf bedtime story…early intervention….you can never start their golf education too soon.

Stitch leather covers are terrifying or simply cute.

Stitch leather covers are terrifying or simply cute.

The old traditional look in all colors and sizes.

The old traditional look in all colors and sizes.

Need help marking that ball?

Need help marking that ball?

Or a major pimped out set of wheels for the ride from the condo to the clubhouse.

A major pimped out set of wheels for the ride from the condo to the clubhouse.

There were celebrity appearances….some live….some Memorex

Butch Harmon...the grand master of instruction...signing lids.

Butch Harmon…the grand master of instruction…signing lids.

Jordan Spieth made a female fan's day.

Jordan Spieth made a young fan’s day.

Jesper and A. Blitz sharing war stories.

Jesper and A. Blitz sharing war stories.

A time-phased appearance by the greatest of them all.

A time-phased appearance by the greatest of them all.

Some people cannot stay out of the public notice.

Some folks cannot stay out of the public eye.

Some tips from a more current "Master".

Some tips from a more current “Master”.

And there there were new concepts….some you would never dream of.

Fling golf kind of a cross between lacrosse and golf.

Fling golf kind of a cross between lacrosse and golf.

Telic Golf Recovery Footwear....Crocs rediscovered (Made In America).

Telic Golf Recovery Footwear….Crocs rediscovered (Made In America).

Reunion.....twin brothers from different mothers.

Reunion…..twin brothers from different mothers.

Outing an age old problem...we all know who they are.

Outing an age old problem…we all know who they are.

As you can see all bases are covered, no stones left unturned…..it is quite a show!

January, 2015

Nona Blue

Nona BlueAs anyone knows who has gone on a group golf trip the only thing secondary to the course venues in the eating establishments for dinner. If you are vacationing in Orlando then you owe it to yourself to check out Nona Blue-Modern Tavern just a pitching wedge from the Lake Nona Golf and Country Club.

This place was opened in the Spring of 2013 by restauranteurs Joe Davi and Bill Bona who tactically attracted Graeme McDowell to invest in the venture and give it some PGA Tour allure. These guys had a focused concept to create a casual tavern with a robust menu of comfort food-a little piece of Killarney heaven in South Florida.

People kickin' back at the outdoor and indoor bars.

People kickin’ back at the outdoor and indoor bars.

The smell of hickory grilled offerings and golf memorabilia welcome you as you step through the door. The bar centric arrangement of the place with surrounding booths and tables relate a hamish feeling that this is a place for some Craic (Irish for revelry) and to hang with friends.

The Graeme McDowell influence hovers above the bar.

The Graeme McDowell influence hovers above the bar.

And greets you buy the door.

And greets you buy the door.

Lest not forget the Major!

Lest not forget the Major!

In spite of the GMac association the decor of the place is not over-golfed. Black and white photos adorn the walls of generational icons like George Burns, Steve McQueen, Rodney Dangerfield, and many others of blessed memory.

Wall Art

Quotes from old favorites.

Quotes from old favorites from our past.

Einstein said...tried golf...too complicated.

Einstein said…tried it once…too complicated.

Posters and maps of the British Isles and other Irish memorabilia give it the place the flavor of the old country.

PortrushNorthern IrelandWe sat down and they handed us the menu…..comfort food sensory overload.

Menu(Click to see a PDF of the Nona Blue Menu)

We started with an array of mouth watering Shareables-Blue Cheese Kettle Chips, Love Me Tenders, Fire Grilled Artichokes, and Fire Cracker Shrimp. Needless to say they did not last long and it just set us up for the next act.

How about this for starters.

How about this for starters….chips and blue cheese drizzle.

The Handwiches were particularly creative and tasty.

BLT Grilled Cheese got the thumbs up from Double-D...lobster salad/applewood bacon/havarati cheese/texas toast

BLT Grilled Cheese got the thumbs up from Double-D…lobster salad/applewood bacon/havarati cheese/texas toast with a side of cheesy creamed corn.

Country Club-ham/turkey/bacon/cheddar cheese/monterey jack on multi-grain....health food..large portion.

Country Club-ham/turkey/bacon/cheddar cheese/monterey jack on multi-grain….health food..New York Deli portion.

Some went for the Nona Blue Plate Specials like Momma’s Double Stacked Meat Loaf and GMAC and Cheese or Off The Grill Entrees like Steak Frites or Pork Chops.

"Cider Brined" Double Cut Pork Chop.

“Cider Brined” Double Cut Pork Chop…you better be hungry.

Steak Frites for those with less exotic tastes.

Steak Frites for those with less exotic tastes.

We weren’t leaving without testing the Sweet Endings. More sharing of the White Chocolate Cheesecake, the Hot Fudge Brownie Sundae, and, my personal favorite, the Banoffee Pie (Bananas/Toffee/Whipped Cream Shaved Chocolate Flakes).

In the true Irish Pub tradition they even threw in some live music with audience participation.

Just "Two Fat Guys" for the acoustic entertainment.

Just “Two Fat Guys” for the acoustic entertainment.

As you can see our folks were satisfied….

MontersFortunately none of us needed the Urgent Care facility upstairs….these guys thought of everything.

Nona Blue Urgent Care.
January, 2015

Desert Willow-Firecliff Course

Desert Willow LogoThe Firecliff Course at Desert Willow is a desert layout as pleasing as any you will ever lay your eyes on. Hurdzan did a marvelous job creating holes with a desert flavor that is not Arizona target golf. Palm Desert may be an arid flat pancake but you would not know it after the four hours you spend playing this course.The bulldozers had their way raising topography from the desert that is lyric and pleasing to the eye.

The designers pulled from all sides of the flora palette to create incredible sideshows.

The designers pulled from all sides of the flora palette to create supporting sideshows.

.
The landscape artist must have been paid a bundle because there are astonishing compositions of desert flora that surrounds every tee, fairway, and green. Bring your digital camera and a large storage card because you are coming home with a load of photographic memories for the family scrapbook.

Lush fairways, framing palms, and mountain back drops-what a formula.

Lush fairways, framing palms, and ominous mountain back drops-what a formula.

These holes have topographical character of a foothills mountain course even though the mountains are miles away. Well positioned every tee box gives a full view of the challenge ahead. There is an insane amount of bunkers and waste areas full of desert nasties but if you control your shot lines it is a negotiable challenge.

A master of obfuscation Hurdzan did a great job in masking the severity of challenge throughout the holes. The short holes are deceitfully difficult and the long holes have plenty of give to them. This is a course where you must plot your path on each hole carefully to mitigate the risk of pummeling your scorecard but there are times when a bold shot can give you a chance for a pleasing result to brag about over dinner.

Click on any photo for an enhanced view of the image

The first view of the day excites with the full flavor of Firecliff

The first view of the day excites with the full flavor of Firecliff

The slope of 133 from the Blue markers is real but the 6700 yards itself is not overwhelming. I noticed that often the upslope in the landing areas off the tees can steal some roll out especially on the back side where there is a more rolling topography. The green complexes are ingenious, many perched on hills or ledged over waste areas or bunkers so getting a proper angle of approach is very important. On average the greens are small with sweeping shoulder slopes not tiers so you will spend a good part of the day scratching your head wondering why approach shots continue to separate from the flag.

The sand and the scrub add beauty and challenge at the Par 3 3rd.

The sand and the scrub add beauty and challenge at the Par 3 3rd.

The lush surrounds of the first tee box sets the stage for the day. A beautiful sweeping par five stretches out in front of you ambling up to a green set in a hollow beautifully appointed by desert vegetation. Another stunning view off the tee box on the second is framed by the towering mountains that surround the Sonoran Desert. The terrarium adjacent to this green and the carry wilderness on the Par 3 third are a signature look for the Firecliff Course.

The approach to the short 6th should come with a warning label.

The approach to the short 6th should come with a warning label.

The pace of the challenge ramps up quickly with back-to-back strong four pars on the fourth and fifth. These are holes with lots of trouble encroaching on the sides but controlled lines make them eminently playable. The short Par 4 sixth is where the large number lurks. After a position fairway metal off the tee the peninsula green setting and sharply slopped putting surface is an ice bucket challenge if you get too ambitious on your approach. Next is a roller coaster Par 5 that should not present any real threat to the scorecard but what follows to the turn will test your patience.

Another distracting visual frames the 8th green.

Another distracting visual frames the 8th green and the adjacent lagoon.

The Par 3 penultimate holes on each side share the astonishing surrounds of what looks like Gilligan’s lagoon. The 8th is a mere short iron across the hazard to a green set in front of majestic palms and beautifully landscaped sand and flora. This visual is more than distracting so try to keep your focus.

Playing into the 9th and 18th the stature of the clubhouse is revealed.

Playing into the 9th and 18th the stature of the clubhouse is revealed.

The view going down the 9th and 18th is equally engaging with the clubhouse high above the green complexes reminiscent of the finish at Grayhawk in Scottsdale. Water of the left impinges the long approach shot to a narrow green opening so prudent course management may call for a lay up for a pitch and a putt to keep the momentum going.

The inward nine begins with the same look....just more hills.

The inward nine begins with the same look….just more rolling terrain to deal with.

Grab a wrap and a protein bar from the snack area in the clubhouse because an awesome stretch of holes are awaiting. The view off the 10th tee is another jaw dropper as a difficult long Par 4 climbs a ramped hill to a table top green complex. With a long club in hand the abrupt slope to the green will reject timid approach shots so do not hold back. The 11th is another long Par 4 with a blinded carry tee shot over the desert wilderness. This leaves a long approach to a green complex parsed from the side hills by deep grassy depressions on each side. A bogey-bogey start on this side is not something to be worried about.

Full carry required across the long waste area to 12 green.

Full carry required across the long waste area to 12 green.

After a drive into the upslope of the fairway on #12 you are left with an intimidating carry across a massive sea of sand and waste to the green perched on a hill. This is another Kodak moment-you could swear you are in Hawaii and the blue Pacific is just beyond the green.

The Par 5 13th would feel right at home at Pine Valley.

The Par 5 13th would feel right at home at Pine Valley.

Two of the more visual holes of the day follow in a Par 5 and Par 3 respectively. The look up the long 13th is inspiring and intimidating. This is a hole where you have to pick a line and trust it because it is much more user friendly than it appears to the eye. The subtle 14th is a soothing alcove green setting with a large desert accent up the left. You may just want to get into the lotus position on this tee box and chant your mantra for about 20 minutes to settle the mind for the challenging stretch to the house.

How disarming is the tranquility in this presentation at 14.

How disarming is the tranquility in this presentation into the 14th.

At first glance the short Par 4 on #15 appears innocuous but negotiating the approach or up and down save into a precipice green with a small pachyderm buried in the back left corner is fraught with difficulty. A piece of Pine Valley follows on the sand scary 16th which has serpentine sand pit covering the last 50 yards left and shrouding the green.

This would be very soothing if the carry wasn't over water, sand, and scrub into a very narrow green.

Soothing if the carry wasn’t over water right and sand left into a very tight green.

Returning for a second taste of Gilligan’s lagoon on 17 the longer length of the club in your hand makes it incrementally more difficult. Once again don’t get lost in admiring the surrounds because this is a very hard long iron or hybrid to hold on line to the diagonal setting of the green.

There is an eerie feeling looking off the last tee.

There is a sureal feeling looking across the mishugas down the 18th fairway.

The play down the last is a perfect conclusion to a thrilling round of golf. A truncated Par 5 that threatens both your second and third shot can be a real thriller if the back nine Nassau depends on you making par or better. Try to ignore all those people on the clubhouse patio with sentiments against your success, they have witnessed legions before you try to get to the house unscathed.

Once you finish putting out and drive up the hill to the doorstep of the clubhouse take a second to stop and look back up the finishing holes. There is one last Kodak moment from a memorable golf course experience that will prod you to return for more.

Palm Desert, California

Designer: Michael Hurdzan (1997)

Tees      Par      Yardage     Rating     Slope

Black     72         7056          73.6        138
Blue      72          6676         71.7        133
White    72          6173         69.3        124

(Click here to review the Desert Willow-Firecliff Course hole-by-hole descriptions)

For more pictures click to review Postcard From Desert Willow-Firecliff

(Clidk to read a review of the sister course-Desert Willow-Mountain View)