The maintenance of equitable individual handicaps is a tedious labor intensive effort that has been a challenge for golf administrators for over a century. The latest fine tuning with the adoption of the World Handicap System in 2020 by the golf governing bodies has done little to simplify it or make the calculations intelligible.
In the spirit of simplicity I share a snippet I found in Alistar Mackenzie’s “The Spirit of St. Andrews” that fiddles with the handicap calculation issue.
No doubt it is simple, intelligible, and passes most of the tests of logic. It really would be most appropriate for creating a home course handicap and is not readily transferable for play at other places.
In our current realm of multiple tees on our home course, it would take a little adjustment to incur fairness for players in competitions using this “home course handicap” playing from different tees. Also, as suggested by Max Behr, something along similar lines would have to be developed for players whose skill level is beyond 18.
Never to be adopted but it is food for thought.
The Spirit of St. Andrews